How to take mascara off without makeup remover

  Reading time 11 minutes

Removing mascara without a traditional makeup remover may sound daunting, especially when dealing with stubborn waterproof formulas. Certain household items can act as effective substitutes to cleanse away that tenacious eye makeup. Embracing alternative methods for makeup removal is not only convenient when you’re out of your standard products but also opens up a gentler, often more natural, approach to skincare. We will explore various techniques and items you could employ to remove even the most resilient waterproof mascaras while ensuring the health of your delicate eye area.

Understanding Mascara Composition

To understand how to effectively remove mascara without makeup removers, it’s essential to first know what makes it stick. The composition of mascara is generally a mixture of pigments, oils, waxes, and preservatives. The formula that allows it to coat your lashes and stay put does not simply wash off with water due to these binding agents.

Water-soluble vs. Waterproof Mascara

Traditional water-soluble mascaras can often be removed with just warm water and a gentle touch. On the other hand, removing waterproof mascara requires more effort due to its formulation designed to resist water and smudging. The added synthetic compounds make it persistent against tears or rain, which also means we need more than just water for effective makeup removal.

Ingredients That Make Mascara Stick

Ingredients like silicone are common in waterproof mascaras to repel moisture. They create a barrier that keeps the mascara intact, offering that desirable long-lasting effect. However, this also means that these types of mascara are not as easily removed and will not simply come off with water. Because of this, we need to find an oil-based solution that can dissolve these resilient ingredients for gentle yet thorough makeup removal.

Authentic Milwaukee Brewers Shop | How to take mascara off without makeup remover

Preparing to Remove Mascara


The skin around our eyes is delicate, demanding a soft touch and some careful consideration in order to avoid irritation. Gently wiping away waterproof mascara can be a seamless process if you prepare properly by gathering the right tools and ingredients beforehand.

Things You’ll Need

  1. A clean, soft cloth or cotton pads.
  2. A choice of natural oil or other household substitutes for makeup removers.

Ensuring you have everything at hand before you begin is essential for a stress-free and effective mascara removal routine. Let’s break down the methods of removal and the steps to effectively carry them out.

Step-by-step Guide to Removing Mascara

Methods To Remove Mascara

Using Natural Oils

Natural oils are highly effective at removing waterproof mascara without irritating the skin. They break down the makeup effortlessly upon application. Here’s a list of oils that are not only readily available but also gentle on the skin:

  • Coconut Oil: This oil has become a beauty staple in many households, working wonders for both skin and hair. Its moisturizing properties make it a superb option for dissolving mascara. Apply a small amount on a cotton pad and hold it against your lashes for a few seconds, then wiping gently until the product comes off.
  • Olive Oil: Another kitchen favorite, olive oil is rich in fatty acids that can help breakdown the stubborn mascara. Moreover, it’s conditioning for the lashes, leaving them stronger after removal.
  • Almond Oil: Lightweight and non-irritating, almond oil is great for not just makeup removal but also for nurturing your eyelashes after doing so. Its gentle nature minimizes the risk of irritation while effectively cleansing away the makeup.

Using Household Products

When natural oils aren’t within reach, there are common household items you could also use in a pinch:

  • Petroleum Jelly: A thick emollient that can work wonders for stubborn makeup like waterproof mascara. Applying it requires extra care, but its efficacy makes it a viable alternative.
  • Cold Cream: This classic skincare product not only moisturizes but can be very effective in melting away makeup. A dollop applied to eyelashes and then wiped clean can leave your eyes free of makeup residue.

Cleansing with Baby Shampoo

An unexpected but gentle alternative, baby shampoo can help remove eye makeup without causing irritation. Baby wipes or a small dollop of baby shampoo applied with water and cotton pads can create a safe concoction for your lashes. The no-tear formula ensures that if some product does enter the eye, irritation will be minimal. Baby oils are another option, following a similar application method to natural oils. Always use these ingredients with caution to avoid any adverse effects.

Authentic Milwaukee Brewers Shop | How to take mascara off without makeup remover

Tips and Tricks for Mascara Removal

Successfully removing mascara, especially waterproof formulas, can be achieved with patience and the right approach. Below are some additional tips to enhance your makeup removal experience:

Warm WaterSoak a cotton pad in warm water and gently press it against your closed eyelids. This will help loosen the mascara, making it easier to remove.
Coconut OilApply a small amount of coconut oil to a cotton pad and swipe it across your lashes. The oil will break down the mascara, allowing for easy removal.
Olive OilSimilar to coconut oil, olive oil can effectively remove mascara. Apply a small amount to a cotton pad and gently wipe away the mascara.
Cold CreamUse a gentle cold cream to dissolve the mascara. Apply it to your lashes and let it sit for a few minutes before wiping away with a cotton pad.
VaselineApply a thin layer of Vaseline to your lashes and let it sit for a few minutes. Then, use a cotton pad to wipe away the mascara.
Makeup Remover WipesIf you have makeup remover wipes on hand, they can be used to quickly and easily remove mascara. Simply swipe the wipe across your lashes until the mascara is gone.

Preventing Eyelash Loss

Vigorous rubbing can lead to unnecessary loss of eyelashes. To prevent this, always use a gentle wiping action when applying oils or other substances. Letting the product sit for a brief period allows the mascara to dissolve, thus minimizing the need for forceful removal.

Avoiding Irritation

Eye irritation might occur if products enter the eye or if you’re sensitive to certain substances. To prevent this, always test a tiny amount of your chosen product on your skin before using it near your eyes. Doing so will help ensure that you do not have an adverse reaction.

Post-removal Eyelash Care

After the mascara has been removed, don’t neglect your lashes and the delicate skin around your eyes. Rinse the area with warm water to remove any lingering residue. Follow up with a hydrating eye cream or a light dab of natural oil to nourish the skin and lashes. While these substitutes are effective, makeup removers specifically designed for the eyes are typically the safest bet.

Authentic Milwaukee Brewers Shop | How to take mascara off without makeup remover


Taking mascara off without a makeup remover does not have to be an ordeal. From the comfort of your own home, you can resort to items such as natural oils, petroleum jelly, cold cream, or even baby shampoo to get the job done. The key is to always be gentle with the skin around your eyes, perform a patch test to avoid irritation, and follow up with proper lash care. By incorporating these methods into your daily routine, removing waterproof mascara will be effective and safe. Remember, while these household fixes are convenient, it’s important to select the method that works best for you and your skin type.


  1. Can I use water to remove mascara?
    While water alone will not effectively remove waterproof mascara, warm water can help loosen water-soluble mascaras. For waterproof formulas, you will need an oil-based substance to break down the persistent ingredients.
  2. How often should I remove my mascara?
    You should remove your mascara daily, as sleeping with it on can lead to eye irritation, potential infections, and weakened lashes. Make mascara removal a part of your nightly skincare routine.
  3. Is it bad to sleep with mascara on?
    Yes, sleeping with mascara can clog the tiny hair follicles and oil glands on your eyelids, leading to irritation, infections like styes, and even cause lashes to become brittle and break off.
  4. Can these methods cause eye irritation?
    If used improperly or if you have a sensitivity to any of the ingredients, eye irritation can occur. Always perform a patch test and avoid getting these alternatives directly in your eyes. If irritation does occur, rinse your eyes with plenty of water and consult a healthcare professional if necessary.
  5. How to maintain healthy eyelashes post-mascara removal?
    After removing mascara, gently wash the eyelid area with warm water. You may apply a small amount of eyelash conditioner or natural oil like castor oil to nourish your lashes and promote their health. Regular trimming is not necessary and should be avoided as it does not cause eyelashes to grow back thicker or faster. Instead, focus on gentle care and avoidance of harsh chemical treatments.

Related Posts